PUBLIC ACCESS TO NH COURTS COMMITTEE MEETING – 11/29/05 2 Industrial Park Drive Concord, NH 03301 Attendance: Ken Barnes Virginia Martin Ralph Littlefield Alan Cantor Claudia Nixon Cheryl Killam Al Leahy The meeting began at 2:00 PM with introductions. Ralph distributed copies of the members list for everyone’s use. Our meetings will be governed by the instructions from the Commission pertaining to the Right to Know Law. The following information will need to be recorded at each meeting: - Attendance - Minutes of Meeting(s) - Record of Vote on a particular issue (if there is a vote) - Who voted and how they voted (yes or no) - Record of the minority position on each vote. Copies of the meeting notices and all minutes will be sent to Julie Morris at the Commission to be posted on the Web-site and for the record. Discussion took place on the following: - What issues need to be explored by the Committee? Each issue should be limited to one paragraph defining the problem and one outlining the recommendation as to a solution. - How to conduct business (as a Committee as a whole or in sub-groups) - Who will work on which issues? The Committee began by reviewing the five (5) tentative areas to explore that were identified at the last meeting: 1) Are all court buildings accessible to people with disabilities? 2) Are legal costs barriers to public access to the Courts? 3) Are legal procedures themselves a barrier to public access? 4) Is technology being used to improve public access? 5) Are language and communication systems utilized by the Courts barriers to public access? Discussion continued as to whether other items should be added. Everyone was in agreement that staying “targeted” and being focused with a limited number of items would probably be a good idea in terms of being goal-oriented and achieving those goals. It was agreed that Item #4 with regard to technology was not considered a barrier but rather as a tool. It was decided that sub-groups would be established and used as the mechanism to conduct the research on each issue. These sub-groups would then report back to the full Committee, with recommendations to be reviewed and consider. The next question that needed to be addressed, “Do the sub-groups activity need to be made part of the written record and notification process?” It was decided that minutes to each sub group would be written and become part of the written record of the full Committee which would then be submitted to the Commission. Public notice of sub-group meetings would not need to be posted. Ralph said he would ask for clarification at the next Steering Committee meeting and notify everyone if there was a change in this procedure. - 2 - It was also noted that a timeframe needs to be established for the finalization of the issues list. If other members of the Committee (not present at today’s meeting) feel that additional items need to be added to the issues list, they need to be brought to the Committee’s attention as soon as possible. The Committee reviewed the present issues list. A) It was decided to eliminate issue #4 from the issues listed to be reviewed. B) It was decided that Issue #5 (which will now become the new Issue #4) needs to be changed to: “Are there communication, linguistic and cultural barriers to public access?” The following issues were tentatively agreed upon as those to be reviewed by the Committee: 1) Are all court buildings accessible to people with disabilities? 2) Are legal cost barriers to public access to the Courts? 3) Are legal procedures themselves a barrier to public access? 4) Are there communications, linguistic and cultural barriers to public access? The following sub-groups were established to review each issue: Issue 1 - Cheryl Killam, Chair Ralph Littlefield Issue 2 & 3 - Virginia Martin, Chair Ken Barnes Alan Cantor Al Leahy Issue 4 - Claudia Nixon, Chair Virginia Martin The next meeting will be held on Monday, January 9, 2006 from 2:00 PM to 3:30 PM. It was noted that each sub-group would hopefully meet prior to the next Committee meeting and provide a brief report on January 9th. With no further business, the meeting adjourned at 3:30 PM. Submitted by: Elaine Roundy Approved by: Ralph Littlefield enr RL-Public Access to NH Courts Comm. Minutes